Picking Our New Garage Doors (Styles, Finishes & Windows)

Hey Beth,

I have all the measurements, framing, and low-profile hardware figured out for replacing both garage doors (we'll be doing a matching 16' × 7' large door and 9' × 7' small door with quiet wall-mounted openers). Now comes the fun part—we need your eye to pick the style, color/finish, and window layout that will look best with our aged redwood siding!

All of the options below are insulated steel (or composite-over-steel), so they give us the warmth of wood without heavy weight or having to restain them every couple of years. Here are the 4 main style directions, color swatches, and window options:


Option 1: Modern Horizontal Wood-Plank Steel (Best Value & Redwood Match)

Models: Clopay Modern Steel™ Ultra-Grain® Plank or Amarr Northwoods
Flush insulated steel doors printed with non-repeating, multi-tone horizontal wood planks. From the driveway they look like tongue-and-groove timber.

Barnwood Plank Door

Barnwood (aged gray-brown timber) w/ slim vertical windows

Cedar Plank Door

Cedar (warm reddish-brown heartwood) w/ slim vertical windows

Aspen Gray Single and Double Garage Doors

Amarr Northwoods (Aspen Gray) — shown in a 2-door setup like ours!

Kona Plank Door

Kona (rich dark brown) w/ top windows

Clopay Ultra-Grain® Plank Wood Swatches (we can order $5 real metal samples of any of these!):

Barnwood
Barnwood
Coastal Gray
Coastal Gray
Cedar
Cedar
Natural
Natural
Kona
Kona
Espresso
Espresso

Option 2: 3D Molded Composite Faux-Wood (Premium Showstopper Tier)

Models: Clopay Canyon Ridge® Modern or Canyon Ridge® Carriage House
Instead of printed steel, these bond a thick polymer composite skin molded directly from real Cypress and Mahogany boards over an insulated steel core. It has deep 3D wood grain up close (roughly ~2× the price of Option 1, available in Mahogany, Walnut, Medium, or weathered Slate).

Canyon Ridge Modern Plank

Canyon Ridge Modern (3D Clear Cypress plank w/ side windows)

Canyon Ridge Carriage House

Canyon Ridge Carriage House (3D composite stile-and-rail w/ top windows)


Option 3 & 4: Recessed Shaker Woodgrain — OR — Crisp Dark Contrast

Model: Clopay Bridgeport™ Steel (or Modern Steel Flush)
If you prefer classic recessed Shaker framing instead of flat planks—OR if faux-wood next to real aged redwood feels "too close yet slightly different," architects often go with a bold dark contrast (like Matte Black, Charcoal, or Dark Bronze) to frame the redwood beautifully.

Bridgeport Ultra-Grain Walnut

Option 3: Shaker Recessed Panels in Ultra-Grain Walnut

Bridgeport Matte Black

Option 4: Matte Black / Dark Bronze Contrast w/ Top Windows


Window Layout & Glass Privacy Choices

Regardless of which door color we choose, we can configure the windows in 4 ways:

Solid No Windows
A. Solid (No Windows)
Cleanest wood look, max insulation
Slim Vertical Windows
B. Slim Narrow Windows
Down one side or across the top
Wide Rectangular Windows
C. Wide Rectangular
Down one side or across top row
Square Windows
D. Modern Squares
Stacked down one edge

Glass Privacy Options (Frosted lets in tons of daylight without anyone seeing into the garage):

Glass Options: Clear, Frost, Dark Tint, Obscure

How to Try Them On Our Actual House:

You can upload a photo of the front of our garage into Clopay's visualizer tool and swap colors and windows right on our house:
→ Try Doors on Our House (Clopay EZDoor™ Visualizer)

Let me know your favorites on:
1. Style: Horizontal Wood Plank (Option 1), 3D Composite (Option 2), Recessed Shaker (Option 3), or Dark Contrast (Option 4)?
2. Top 3–4 Colors so I can mail-order physical metal sample chips to hold up against our redwood in the sun.
3. Windows: Solid (none), across the top row, or stacked vertically down one side—and Frosted, Tinted, or Clear glass?

Love,
Josh